Our standard buttercream wedding cakes start at $4 per serving. Custom-designed cakes and cakes that are 3-tiers or more start at $5 per serving. The best way to get an accurate quote is to send us an email at with as many details as you have - how many people you need to serve, flavors, design and wedding date. We're happy to design almost anything you can imagine! Our Vermont Wedding Cake portfolio can be viewed here. View starting prices below:

2 Tier Cakes

Medium (serves 50) $200

Large (serves 70) $280

3 Tier Cakes

Medium (serves 80) $400

Large (serves 120) $600

4 Tier Cakes

Medium (serves 130) $650

Large (serves 200) $1000


  • Delivery & set up (weddings only) - $50 within Chittenden County. Contact us for delivery charge estimate.

  • Gluten-free or vegan add $1 per serving

  • Script Cake Topper $20

  • Florals - market price

  • Cake Stand $30 or retail price

  • 100% Organic add $2 per serving

  • Artificial dye-free add $10

  • Fruit Fillings (Raspberry, Strawberry) or Ganache $10-20 per tier

  • Edible metallic finish $10-30 per tier

  • Fondant covered $20-30 per tier

  • Drip $5 per tier

  • Dessert Bar Options: Cookies, Macarons, Truffles & More (contact for pricing)


Custom cake prices vary greatly depending on characters, toppers, colors and overall time and materials required to complete. You can view our custom cake portfolio here. While our starting prices are listed below, the majority of our custom cakes that you see in the portfolio are typically priced from $70-110 for single-tier cakes and $180-250 for two tier cakes:

  • 6 inch round (serves 15) starts at $60

  • 8 inch round (serves 20-25) starts at $80

  • 10 inch round (serves 30-35) starts at $90

  • Number or custom shaped cakes - custom carved in to a shape. Starting at $150

The extras & add on pricing applies to these cakes as well. Tiered custom cakes follow the same pricing as wedding cake options. The best way to get a quote is to send us an email at


For Weddings:

A non-refundable $100 deposit and contract is due to reserve your Vermont wedding cake order. This will be applied towards your final balance. 100% of the balance is due one month prior to the event

For Custom Cakes:

A 50% deposit is required to reserve your date. This is non-refundable. The remaining 50% of the cost is due at the time of delivery. 


Tasting boxes:


Tasting boxes can be prepared for pick up with ample notice, up to four of our classic flavors for $40. 


Tastings are available from November - May and are subject to Cronin Cakes' availability. We ask for 30 days notice for a tasting box.