Our standard buttercream wedding cakes start at $5 per serving. Custom-designed cakes and cakes three-tiers and above start at $5 per serving. Our wedding cakes have 4 layers of cake and three layers of fililng per tier. The best way to get an accurate quote is to fill out our inquiry form with as many details as you have - how many people you need to serve, flavors, design and wedding date. We're happy to design almost anything you can imagine! Our Vermont Wedding Cake portfolio can be viewed here. View starting prices below:

Cutting Cake

Anniversary mini tier - $35

Small (serves 12) - $60

2 Tier Cakes

Medium (serves 50) $240

Large (serves 70) $340

3 Tier Cakes

Medium (serves 80) $480

Large (serves 120) $720

4 Tier Cakes

Medium (serves 130) $780

Large (serves 200) $1200


  • Anniversary tier - mini cake boxed and ready to freeze $25

  • Gluten-free or vegan add $1 per serving

  • Script Cake Topper $20

  • Florals - market price

  • Cake Stand $30 or retail price

  • Fruit Fillings (Raspberry, Strawberry) or Ganache $10-20 per tier

  • Edible metallic finish $30 per tier

  • Fondant covered $20-30 per tier

  • Drip $5 per tier


White Wedding


Classic white vanilla cake with vanilla swiss-meringue buttercream. Add a filling like raspberry, lemon or passion fruit curd if you like!

Apple Spice

Warmly-spiced cakes baked with Vermont apple chunks inside. Frosted with cinnamon swiss-meringue buttercream. Add caramel between layers for an extra treat!

Vanilla-Almond Raspberry

Vanilla-almond cake with raspberry fruit filling, surrounded by vanilla swiss-meringue buttercream

Brown Sugar Maple

Vermont maple syrup & brown sugar cake, filled with a touch of even more maple syrup and maple swiss-meringue buttercream.

Chocolate Wedding

Rich Ghiradelli chocolate cake with a silky chocolate buttercream. Fill with chocolate ganache for triple chocolate!

Lemon Berry

Fresh lemon cake filled with a berry compote of your choice. We recommend  raspberry-filled or blueberry-filled with mascarpone buttercream.


Classic carrot cake with finely-shredded carrots and walnuts if desired. Filled with cream cheese frosting


Our classic yellow cake recipe with fun-colored sprinkles in the cake & vanilla swiss-meringue buttercream. Choose an American buttercream if you like your frosting sweet!


Looking for variety? We offer a few other desserts, pricing listed below*:

  • Cupcakes, $30/dozen

  • Macarons (vanilla, almond, pistachio or raspberry), $30/dozen

  • Cookies $25/dozen

  • Brownies, $25/dozen

  • Raspberry almond bars, $30/dozen

  • Lemon bars $30/dozen

  • Chocolate peanut-butter bars


*We ask for a minimum of 2 dozen per dessert ordered



Inquire about your date via through our inquiry form. Please include approximate guest number, what you are looking for (cakes, cupcakes, desserts) and most importantly your date.

We'll give you a pricing estimate and ask clarifying questions if needed.


If you'd like to try flavors prior to contract, you can order a tasting box. In 2022, we have select dates open for tasting box pick-up: Feb 11, March 11, April 9, Nov 11 and Dec 9. We cannot accommodate other dates for tasting boxes and there are no tasting box dates during peak wedding season (May - October). Please remember that your date can only be held with a deposit & contract received. We do not hold dates even if you are awaiting a tasting.

Tasting boxes will include up to 4 of our wedding cake flavors above.

We are not offering seated tastings at this time.


A non-refundable $100 deposit and contract is due to reserve your Vermont wedding cake order. This will be applied towards your final balance. 100% of the balance is due one month prior to the event. Dates will not be reserved without a deposit.


That's ok! You can make changes to flavors an design up to a month prior to your event. However, we ask that if you are changing guest count that you not go below 75% of the cost of your contract. 


We highly recommend delivery and set up of all wedding orders for your own piece of mind! Delivery and set up is $50 per hour of travel required by Cronin Cakes, round trip. 

We like to arrive 2-3 hours prior to your ceremony to set up but will confirm delivery time with you prior to your wedding date.